It is the perennial question for authors, editors, agents,
booksellers and librarians. What do readers want? What are the elements of a
satisfying read?
I am a lucky member of a middle school book club. I joined
this book club with my son when he was in fifth grade, and he has since decided
being in a book club is not something that interests him anymore. (Killing me
softly, these boys of mine who don’t read enough.)
Lucky for me, there are eager readers in this bunch who
allow me to stay without my child in tow. As an author for the young adult and
middle grade audiences, I feel privileged to hear what they have to say about
what they are reading.
Tonight, I heard these young readers appreciate neat
storylines that tie up at the end of a book. Quiet stories “where nobody dies”
are sought out by some. Surprising news is that these particular young readers
do not like character growth in minor characters. In one case, the mother in
the story gives up her obsession with horoscopes, realizing she cannot predict
her life from those words on a page. The young reader told me she didn’t like
it when the mother gave up her horoscopes, because that was something that made
her love the character.
The idea that not all characters need to change is new to
me, and I appreciate this input from readers. Most of the advice I hear is from
professionals ensconced in the business or writers who broke in or hope to
break in. I enjoy the fresh look of a reader looking at the
genre for the first time.
I can’t wait for this group to get to YA novels. I hope they
don’t kick me out before we get to Cinder.